EU police data plans raise serious privacy and security concerns
Written by Nicole Cappella Thu 19 Dec 2024

The plans by the European Union to give police greater access to personal data have been greeted with alarm by those advocating for privacy, businesses, and civil society.
More than 50 organisations signed an open letter, from NGOs and journalist unions to tech companies and legal associations, addressed to the EU Justice and Home Affairs Council, warning that changing police access to data could gravely undermine human rights and digital security for citizens of Europe.
The letter, organised by European Digital Rights (EDRi), criticises the recommendations of the High Level Group regarding access to data for law enforcement. An issue is a movement to grant law enforcement greater access to personal data, which the signatories say could result in privacy abuses and mass surveillance.
Weakened Encryption and Digital Security
The letter specifically calls out the concept of ‘lawful access by design’ which is the idea that law enforcement access would be baked into the development of digital technologies. In effect, it would require that a back door be created in otherwise secure applications so that police could gain access to the data within. Critics of the plan say that this will undermine encryption and compromise the security of digital communications, which would ‘put everyone’s safety at risk and severely encroach people’s fundamental rights’.
While the intention of ‘lawful access by design’ is to improve crime prevention, weakening encryption increases systemic vulnerabilities that could be leveraged by malicious actors at the expense of the safety of people, businesses, and institutions. Signatories of the letter urge that this recommendation be rejected, along with any other measure that may bypass or weaken encryption, in order to protect the privacy of confidential information for regular citizens.
The signatories also warn such extensive surveillance powers can be abused in ways to target journalists, activists, and political dissidents, undermining the EU’s commitment to protecting human rights and democracy.
Mass Surveillance
Another issue raised in the EDRi letter is that data retention restrictions will extend to almost all digital services, which could allow the untargeted, indiscriminate retention of personal data. This action would be contrary to the principles of necessity and proportionality anchored in EU law.
The letter goes on to state that this type of indiscriminate data collection and retention feeds a culture of surveillance, which risks stifling freedoms of expression, association, and other civil liberties.
While the groups that oppose the HLG recommendations recognise that there is an effort being made to update police procedures to accommodate the digital age, they still hold that these changes should not ‘be achieved at the expense of weakening fundamental rights, legal safeguards, and the European economy’.
Police Turns to Technology to Solve Crime
In recent years, law enforcement has turned to technologies to tackle evolving criminal challenges but has often been met with scrutiny. In February, the UK Justice and Home Affairs Committee said it is investigating the use of Live Facial Recognition (LFR) by police forces in England and Wales and has called for legislation on the technology.
Baroness Hamwee, the Chair of the Committee, wrote in a letter to the Home Secretary, James Cleverly, with recommendations for clear standards and regulations to enable the legal deployment of LFR technology. She also emphasised the importance of ensuring consistent training in LFR usage across England and Wales.
In October 2023, UK police were urged to double their use of artificial intelligence (AI) facial recognition technology by May 2024. In a letter to police chiefs, Policing Minister Chris Philp emphasised the need for law enforcement to embrace innovative technologies to prevent and solve crimes as criminal activity evolves. The Government stressed facial recognition is strictly governed by data protection, equality, and human rights laws. It can only be used by the police where it is necessary and proportionate.
Written by Nicole Cappella Thu 19 Dec 2024
Most Viewed News
Wed 4 Nov 2026
Drax announces £20bn AI data centre plans in North YorkshireFri 6 Nov 2026
Global tech stocks fall amid concerns over AI spending
